Simple Do-it-yourself Pumpkin Pie

The attract of pumpkin pie lies not simply in its wealthy, golden hue, however within the symphony of flavors it guarantees with each chew. A trademark of festive celebrations, this dessert captures the essence of autumn, combining the earthy sweetness of pumpkin with a medley of heat spices. Encased in a buttery crust, every slice tells a narrative of custom, consolation, and culinary delight. Whether or not it’s the nostalgia it evokes or the anticipation of that first delectable chew, pumpkin pie beckons each seasoned bakers and learners to expertise its magic.

Ingredient Breakdown & Substitutions

Pumpkin Puree

  • Perform: Offers the bottom and fundamental taste profile of the pie.
  • Substitutions: Butternut squash or candy potato puree for a unique, but related taste.

Sweetened Condensed Milk

  • Perform: Provides sweetness and creamy texture.
  • Substitutions: A combination of cream and sugar, or unsweetened condensed milk with added sugar; for a dairy-free choice, coconut condensed milk.


  • Perform: Act as a binding agent to set the filling.
  • Substitutions: A store-bought egg replacer for a plant-based different, discovered subsequent to the eggs or within the plant-based, refrigerated part of your grocery retailer.

Cinnamon, Ginger, and Nutmeg

  • Perform: These spices present the signature heat taste synonymous with pumpkin pie.
  • Substitutions: 2 teaspoons of pumpkin pie spice as a direct substitute, or a mixture of allspice and clove for the same spice profile.

Unbaked Pie Crust

  • Perform: Holds the filling and provides texture distinction with its flaky layers.
  • Substitutions: Graham cracker crust, cookie crumb crust, or a gluten-free crust for dietary wants.

Regularly Requested Questions

Is store-bought pie crust appropriate for this pie?

Completely! We desire a selfmade crust, however store-bought crusts are additionally OK to make use of.

Can I make the pumpkin puree for this pie?

If you wish to actually develop your abilities with regards to pumpkin pies you may strive making the pumpkin puree your self. A sugar pumpkin is greatest if you’ll find it. It’s a smaller pumpkin, and must be obtainable at your native grocery retailer.

To make pumpkin puree, halve or quarter your pumpkin to extra simply take away the seeds. Then, cook dinner your pumpkin.

You possibly can both:
– Bake within the oven at 375 levels Fahrenheit for 45 minutes.
– Steam for about 20 to half-hour on the stovetop.

Then, take away the pores and skin. As soon as the pumpkin flesh has softened from cooking it may possibly simply be scraped from the pores and skin. Final, puree it up in a blender, meals processor, or with a potato masher.

The essential concept behind pumpkin puree is that you need to cook dinner the pumpkin after which simply puree it. A pumpkin isn’t any totally different than different winter squashes.

Ought to I take advantage of a pie defend?

Pies like this bake for fairly a little bit of time within the oven. As a result of each oven works only a bit in another way chances are you’ll add a pie shield midway by means of baking. You can too make your individual defend out of aluminum foil. Some ovens simply brown greater than others on prime, so keep watch over that outer crust.

Can I make this in a deep dish pie plate?

Sadly, no. A deep dish pie plate is way deeper than a daily pie plate and requires about 50% extra filling. A shallow, common sized pie is the right pie to crust ratio with regards to pumpkin.

Do I have to par-bake the crust?

Par-baking, or partially baking the pie crust earlier than including the filling, shouldn’t be strictly crucial for pumpkin pie, however it may be useful. It could actually assist to stop the crust from turning into soggy as soon as the moist filling is added.

For those who desire a crispier backside crust, par-baking for about 10 minutes can create a barrier that retains the moisture out. Nonetheless, for those who’re quick on time or just desire a softer crust, you may skip this step and bake the pie as directed with the raw crust. Simply make sure you bake it till the sides are properly browned, and the underside crust is cooked by means of.

Pie Crust

For this recipe you will have an unbaked pie crust. You should use a:

  • Do-it-yourself crust
  • Frozen crust
  • Roll out, pre-made crust

Our private favourite is a homemade graham cracker crust!

Step-By-Step Visible Information to Do-it-yourself Pumpkin Pie

Photo collage of the process of making a pumpkin pie with an unbaked pie crust, raw ingredients in a glass bowl, pouring the pumpkin pie mix into th unbaked pie crust, and a whole unbaked pumpkin pie.


  • Runny Filling: The filling could be undercooked or have an excessive amount of moisture. Make sure you comply with the baking instances and temperature suggestions.
  • Soggy Backside: Blind baking the pie crust for a couple of minutes earlier than including the filling will help stop this.
  • Burnt Crust: Protect the sides of your crust with foil in the event that they’re browning too shortly.
  • Cracked Filling: Make sure the pie cools slowly to stop floor cracks. Fast temperature adjustments may cause the filling to crack.

Ideas From the Chef

  • Blind baking the pie crust for a couple of minutes can stop a soggy backside.
  • Protect the sides of your crust with foil to stop over-browning.
A spatula pulling a piece of pumpkin pie out of the pie plate.

Storage & Freezing Directions

Pumpkin pie might be saved within the fridge for as much as 4 days. For those who’d wish to freeze your pie, wrap it tightly in plastic wrap after which aluminum foil. It may be saved frozen for as much as 2 months. When able to eat, thaw within the fridge in a single day.

Eat Extra Pumpkin!

Watch the video under the place Caytlin will stroll you thru each step of this recipe. Generally it helps to have a visible, and we’ve all the time bought you coated with our cooking present. You will discover the whole assortment of recipes on YouTube, Facebook Watch, or our Facebook Page, or proper right here on our web site with their corresponding recipes.

Trending Merchandise


We will be happy to hear your thoughts

Leave a reply

Register New Account
Shopping cart